Pulitzer Prize–winning historian Barbara W. Tuchman, author of the World War I masterpiece The Guns of August, grapples with her boldest subject. Current U.S. politics can be defined by what the historian referred to in her book “The March of Folly” as a “wooden-headedness” in. IN her latest book, Barbara W. Tuchman – the author of such . But any way one approaches ”The March of Folly,” it is unsatisfying, to say the.

Author: Sak Arashigrel
Country: South Sudan
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Medical
Published (Last): 16 March 2015
Pages: 378
PDF File Size: 1.14 Mb
ePub File Size: 17.22 Mb
ISBN: 874-8-93458-989-6
Downloads: 23112
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Jucage

Tuchman defines folly as the pursuit by government of policies contrary to their own interests, despite the availability of feasible alternatives.

In the notes of his early life, writing of himself in the third person, Solon put it differently: Read it Forward Read tuchmman first. In fact she points out: As another example, it can only be folly if another reasonable alternative choice is available yet the counter productive choice is made. Want to Read saving…. However most of military leaders were not at all convinced that Vietnam presented any real threat tolly U.

While this is not the most gripping of Tuchman’s writings, it is a very readable exploration of the blindness of those who often lead nations into conflicts they cannot win. The premise was so promising, noted historian takes a four egregious disatsers the trojan horse, the papal actions in the lead up to Luther, the loss of the american colonies and the Vietnam war to understand what led to garbara decisions.

I would call this a must for history fans or fans of military history.

Ignore my suggestions at your own risk. Second, the account of the involvements of France and the United States in VietNam is of a journalistic quality not in keeping with the rest of the book, though it may well have been her motive for writing it. I found this to be the most interesting section as time and time again the politicians chose to ignore the facts and opinions of many to pursue an un-winnable conflict.

Whether that was bad luck or was owing to the almost exclusive hold of the ultraprivileged on decision-making positions is not clear beyond question. This is, as she argues, a view of uninformed people not understanding Southeast Asia nor the relative roles of Russian and China in the desired spread of Communism. I find this curious indeed and have been wondering for some time why it is so.


Immediately after Kennedy was elected in the North declared a war of unification of Vietnam. It’s a fascinating variation on a theme and story I have read about many times over but barbarw from this angle. The Vietnam War was a badly managed war and was fought for troubling reasons, but I struggle to call it completely vain in purpose the way that Tuchman does.

The March of Folly – Wikipedia

The Renaissance Popes and the Protestant Reformation: Books by Barbara W. Heck, if she’d just decided to write a book about the US and Vietnam, I’d have more respect for it. So I think you can read this book for its individual content i. We are a prideful, belligerent, deceitful, artful, malignant, umbragious — a word I learned in reading this book—species.

None of the sections work as straight narrative: The examples used are valid and make sense.

These include the Trojans’s unaccountable bringing of the Trojan horse into Troy; the transgressions of the Renaissance Popes which brought on the Reformation; the loss by Britain of the American colonies; and America’s own pointless war in Vietnam.

Also by Barbara W. Insightful, particularly for a history noob like myself, Barb’s writing is full of relevant advice, reflected in the mistakes of the past.

Lastly, Tuchman writes how the US lost in Vietnam. Tuchman applies the concept of folly to historical “mistakes” with certain features in common: She managed to keep me engaged with her stylish delivery, but I think this segment was likely included in order to have the book span a larger swatch of world history. She begins with the story of the Trojan Horse to illustrate the first written example of governmental folly leading to disaster.

In “The March of Folly,” one begins to wonder if she has not strayed too far afield and is rather unsure of her ground. Or it may be that this apparent instability is founded on limited research and that that has been allowed to come through in the book. However, Tuchman presents the circumstances leading to and pushing forward the American Revolution from the perspective of the Tuchmna parliament and government officials.


Fklly a pretty tuchmaan theme that in encapsulate tons of examples. On the one hand, it’s too mqrch — at about pages per part, it becomes a slog to get through each.

The March of Folly

But it is a powerful story, and not a bad way to bring up themes, though I don’t know that it’s overly successful tuhcman. Perhaps this first fault leads to the second, although not entirely. I think I have felt very keenly the feelings of many of our young men concerning this terrible conflict in which we are engaged, but I am sure we are there because of a great humanitarian spirit in utchman hearts of the people of this nation.

I just never became convinced of the unity of the whole. The American Revolution chapter in particular was especially intriguing.

Tuchman’s folly | The New Criterion

It’s just amazing, the utter blindness and stupidity of maarch of the people in high places, from way, way back, up to the present time. Tuchman By Barbara W.

See 1 question about The March of Folly…. However, Tuchman has provided an incredible addition to the study of these particular events. It is this section where the case for folly, though clearly presented, is much more complicated and relies heavily on the examples from the previous sections.


The March of Folly: From Troy to Vietnam

When I was in the 4th grade I found a book that my Mom had to read for college in the back of a cupboard. The French had held Vietnam before WWII and wanted to reestablish its control after the war, but the Vietnamese were rebelling against this colonial rule. Having said all of that while interesting the whole book feels like you could have also picked examples where some of those features led to unliekly success.

I particularly When I was in the 4th grade I found a book that my Mom had to read for college in the back of a cupboard.

May 13, Susan rated it it was amazing.